http://www.waste-management-world.com/index/waste-to-energy.html
Under the terms of the yet to be finalised contract, a
"framework" has been released that would see the city
would pay $9.1 million a year to Plasco, if it takes those 300
tonnes a day - 109,500 tonnes a year, or roughly a third of
Ottawa's household waste. "The agreement, in my opinion,
is a good deal for taxpayers and it's also a good deal for the
environment and I'm going to support it," Watson is
reported to have said. "Digging a hole and putting garbage in
it in the 21st century just doesn't make a whole lot of
sense."
The company is currently making efforts to commercialise its plasma
gasification, which instead of using plasma torches directly on the
waste uses them only to refine the gases released from the
gasification of the waste. Because of the city's early support
for the Plasco, it reportedly stands to receive payments if the
company builds commercial plants elsewhere. The 20 year contract is
reported to have options to be extended to 40 years. Depending on
how successful the company is a 40 year deal would cost the city
between $400,000 and $950,000 a year more than the status quo of
dumping most of its household waste in the Trail Road landfill.
However, the report said that that does not account for the
eventual cost of finding a new landfill
<http://www.waste-management-world.com/index/landfill.html>
site is full. The city puts that cost at $250 million and
Toronto recently paid $220 million to buy a private landfill for
its own use. Ottawa's city government is said to estimates that
under existing conditions, the Trail Road landfill would have to
close in 2042, but the 300 tonne per day deal with Plasco would
extend that to 2070.
Critics
According to CBC television News - which the
covered the full day of questions by city councillors, the
ministry, interested groups and citizens as the deal was recently
passed by a margin of seven to one - critics of the deal have said
the city should not pin its hopes on an unproven technology.
Some have questioned the potential impact that the facility could
have on the city's recycling rate.
while Rod Muir of the Sierra Club of Canada is reported to have
said he's crunched the data from Plasco's trial runs and
has concerns.
Muir was at Ottawa City Hall to address councillors on the
environment committee where he expressed his doubts about Plasco
converting, what he calls, "spotty" test results into a
reliable commercial operation.
"It has never worked successfully on mixed municipal solid
waste," Muir is reported to have. "It hasn't here
either...It has never worked anywhere."
However, aware that Plasco's process has never been deployed at
a full scale permanent facility that runs to a steady schedule,
Watson is reported to have said that he's satisfied that the
contract contains enough protections for Ottawa if Plasco can't
do what it promises.
"At the end of the day, if the process doesn't work,
that's Mr. Bryden (CEO of Plasco) and Plasco's problem,
it's not the taxpayers' problem," added Watson.